Shane Gold
Shane Gold, Compliance Officer at First State Super

Website

Does Either .com Or .com.au Domain Have An Advantage? ✅

If an online business has customers globally and the .COM domain name (first choice) is not available, is it better to choose another .COM domain name (2nd choice) or stick with the first choice but register it as .COM.AU? If registered as .COM.AU, what effect does this have (if any) in terms of Google ranking? For example, if the website has a page 1 ranking in Australia, is it also ranked #1 if someone from the USA or UK does the same keyword search? Any advice is greatly appreciated.

User
Loading

5 Answers

Chee Chun (Cheech) Foo

Chee Chun (Cheech) Foo , Director at Ignite Search

This is a common question and definitely an important one to clarify. I was involved with a major re-brand and re-design project with a leading Apartment Hotel operator in Australia and we were contemplating the exact same thing about 8 months ago.

A bit of history first. It used to be that 10 years ago, Google uses the ccTLD or the country code Top Level Domains to determine how relevant your site is to a particular country.

Now it has become much more sophisticated and Google is now smarter. If you read up on the reference links shown below, there are many ways in which Google can implicitly try to define your target country without needing to get a ccTLD. These can include your geotargeting settings in Google Webmaster Tools (GWT), your server location, even your geotargeting redirects if you happen to have one or more sites. (We implemented this on a site which was getting confused between two identical sites and the moment we implemented the 302 geotargeting redirects, the traffic and rankings bounced back).

Also, there are instances where if you your site is authoritative and relevant enough you are able to rank in the top spot even if you are a .com. look at the hotel industry where www.wotif.com is consistently ranking highly. The hotels industry is a case where the market is global-based rather than just local-based. Therefore these sites like Wotif have reason to invest in content around hotels in Australia and also because it's a pay-now, experience later service; pre-purchase persuasion is important.

Perhaps a reason why .com (or general TLDs) in other verticals are not performing as well is because there is no reason to. E.g. why would Bank of Canada create large content hubs about Australia, given their limited presence? Also Australian sites won't link to it as much as they would to the Big 4 banks.

In short, if your business is primarily based in Australia, then I would personally lean towards going for a .com.au domain with a server based in Australia (or if you guys are very keen, go for a cloud-based solution such as Amazon Web Services (AWS), Akamai or others.

Of course in the end, SEO recommendations go hand in hand with business considerations so you must always take that into account when making such a fundamental change to your site.

Cheers,

Cheech

References:

http://support.google.com/webmasters/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=2712858 http://support.google.com/webmasters/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=62399&topic=2371325&ctx=topic 

Wendy Huang

Wendy Huang , Full Time Blogger and YouTuber at A Custom Blog in 4 Minutes

One of the best answers I've seen on the site as yet :) Keep up em coming Cheech!
One of the best answers I've seen on the site as yet :) Keep up em coming Cheech!
Chee Chun (Cheech) Foo

Chee Chun (Cheech) Foo , Director at Ignite Search

Thanks Wendy!
Thanks Wendy!
View all replies
User
Matt Antonino

Matt Antonino , owner & SEO consultant at Pay On Performance

You will have a hard time ranking .com.au on Google.com and vice versa.  It's possible but unlikely to show up on anything resembling a moderate difficulty keyword.

Second choice domain name if it's available in .com, .com.au and .co.uk is best.  Then you can decide how to proceed on the international sites.  I do this with my own site.  I have .com and .com.au  - my .com shows up on Google.com and my .com.au shows up on Google.com.au  

Your rankings will vary greatly across the international versions of Google based on local and international competition, personalized search locations, etc.

Shane Gold

Shane Gold , Compliance Officer at First State Super

Thanks Matt. Does that mean if I choose a .COM site, I will still have a hard time ranking in Australian Google?
Thanks Matt. Does that mean if I choose a .COM site, I will still have a hard time ranking in Australian Google?
Matt Antonino

Matt Antonino , owner & SEO consultant at Pay On Performance

Not as hard as trying to rank a .com.au on Google.com, no. You can rank .coms anywhere but country-specific rarely rank off the country-specific Google. Wi... read more
Not as hard as trying to rank a .com.au on Google.com, no. You can rank .coms anywhere but country-specific rarely rank off the country-specific Google. With Google trending toward "local" and "brands" the last thing you want to do is try to rank a .com.au on Google.com to a search user in Chicago or London. Unless my businesses were hyper-local and one country only, I'd only take .com domains. If I had a small store in Melbourne, maybe I'd settle for a .com.au but international or online business, no way. .com only, I'd think.
View all replies
User
Peter Jones

Peter Jones , Founder at LinkSmart

Hi,
I have a laymans point of view about domain names. On the whole there are maybe 4 ways a domainname will be found/used.
1. They type it from a business card etc
2. Find it on a Google search
3. Click thu from another site.
4. Someone guessing the domainname.
In my  opinion none of the first 3 of the above will care what your domain name (com or com.au) is as long as it has something relevent to your business name. Only the forth one would you require the .au and most people will include it in Australia
Regards
Peter


User
Tom Valcanis

.au domain names are industry regulated while .com names are not.

.au domain names are regulated by the .au Domain Administration. They are a not-for-profit company endorsed by the Federal Government. oversee and enforce three main aspects of the domain name industry

- Domain name policy: who can register certain .au domain names (eligibility and allocation)

- Delegation of registry function (who runs the entire .au registry - AusRegistry)

- Accreditation of registrars (companies that register domain names for consumers, such as GoDaddy etc.)

The domain name policy protects consumers because com.au and .net.au domains must be purchased by ABN holders. This means you can trace the .au domain back to a registered entity. This theoretically prevents scams, etc. Policies also cover:

- Monetisation and mispellings (you can't just sit on a domain name forever without using it, nor can you register an obvious misspelling of a known domain to scam people)

- Allocation and eligibility (you can't register a domain name unless it has a close or substantial connection to your business, for example)

- Domain name arbitration (in case there are contested claims to a domain name, such as partnership breakups - which is known to happen.)

This is kind of a long winded way to say .au should be more trustworthy than a .com name, if you are looking for Australian businesses to deal with. a .com could literally be "anyone," where .au is a registered business that is based in Australia (or has dealings in Australia.)

User
Geoffrey frank

Well .au is a country code for top level domain whose delegation is discussed in RFC 1591. Using ccTLC can boost SEO of your website by triggering it for that particular country. However there are still two views of experts about the use of ccTLD i.e. few find it useful for SEO while other not.

The ccTLD is a simplest approach to signify Google that site belongs to which country. There are other parameters too that Google uses to identify the belonging country but those are quite complicated.

User